ImageMagick – Security Policy
Author: ImageMagick Studio LLC
Description: ImageMagick is a powerful, open-source software suite for creating, editing, converting, and manipulating images in over 200 formats. Ideal for web developers, graphic designers, and researchers, it offers versatile tools for image processing, including batch processing, format conversion, and complex image transformations.
Keywords: Security Policy, Image Processing, Digital Image Editing, Image Conversion, Open-Source Software, Image Manipulation, Command-Line Image Tools

# Security Policy

Security Policy • Example Security Policy • Pixel Cache Synchronize Policy • Zero Configuration Security Policy • Other Security Considerations

It is strongly recommended to establish a security policy suitable for your local environment before utilizing ImageMagick.

The default policy is open, which is useful for ImageMagick installations running in a secure environment, such as in a Docker container or behind a firewall.

ImageMagick is a tool that allows you to manipulate images. While it offers a range of features and capabilities, there is often a trade-off between security and convenience. To ensure optimal security, you can restrict ImageMagick to only reading or writing web-safe image formats like GIF, JPEG, and PNG. Alternatively, you can customize the security policy to fit the needs of your local environment or organizational policies. This policy can include details such as memory usage limits, allowed paths for reading and writing, limits on the number of images in a sequence, maximum workflow runtime, allowed disk space for image pixels, a secret passphrase for remote connections, and which coders are permitted or denied. By customizing the security policy, you can help secure your environment and ensure that ImageMagick is a responsible member of your local system, such as by preventing overloading with large images.

It is important to set limits on ImageMagick's resource usage to prevent potentially harmful situations. For example, if you accidentally download an image from the internet that has been crafted to generate a very large image (e.g., 20000 by 20000 pixels), ImageMagick may try to allocate the necessary resources (such as memory and disk space) and your system may deny the request or cause the program to exit. Alternatively, your computer may become temporarily slow or unresponsive, or ImageMagick may be forced to abort. To avoid such situations, you can set limits in the policy.xml configuration file.

Keep in mind that what is considered reasonable for one environment may not be suitable for another. For example, you may have ImageMagick sandboxed in a secure environment, while someone else may use it to process images on a publicly accessible website. Or, ImageMagick may be running on a host with a lot of memory, while another instance is running on a device with limited resources. In the case of the host with large memory, it may make sense to allow large image processing, but not on the device with limited resources. If you are using ImageMagick on a public website, you may want to increase security by disabling certain coders such as MVG or HTTPS.

To help you get started, as of version 6.9.12-94, ImageMagick provides security polices that you can select when installing ImageMagick. Choose from:

open
  The default policy for ImageMagick installations is the open security policy. This policy is designed for usage in secure settings like those protected by firewalls or within Docker containers. Within this framework, ImageMagick enjoys broad access to resources and functionalities. This policy provides convenient and adaptable options for image manipulation. However, it's important to note that it might present security vulnerabilities in less regulated conditions. Thus, organizations should thoroughly assess the appropriateness of the open policy according to their particular use case and security prerequisites.
limited
  The primary objective of the limited security policy is to find a middle ground between convenience and security. This policy involves the deactivation of potentially hazardous functionalities, like specific coders such as SVG or HTTP. Furthermore, it establishes several constraints on the utilization of resources like memory, storage, and processing duration, all of which are adjustable. This policy proves advantageous in situations where there's a need to mitigate the potential threat of handling possibly malicious or demanding images, all while retaining essential capabilities for prevalent image formats.
secure
  This stringent security policy prioritizes the implementation of rigorous controls and restricted resource utilization to establish a profoundly secure setting while employing ImageMagick. It deactivates conceivably hazardous functionalities, including specific coders like SVG or HTTP. The policy promotes the tailoring of security measures to harmonize with the requirements of the local environment and the guidelines of the organization. This protocol encompasses explicit particulars like limitations on memory consumption, sanctioned pathways for reading and writing, confines on image sequences, the utmost permissible duration of workflows, allocation of disk space intended for image data, and even an undisclosed passphrase for remote connections. By adopting this robust policy, entities can elevate their overall security stance and alleviate potential vulnerabilities.
websafe
  This security protocol designed for web-safe usage focuses on situations where ImageMagick is applied in publicly accessible contexts, like websites. It deactivates the capability to read from or write to any image formats other than web-safe formats like GIF, JPEG, and PNG. Additionally, this policy prohibits the execution of image filters and indirect reads, thereby thwarting potential security breaches. By implementing these limitations, the web-safe policy fortifies the safeguarding of systems accessible to the public, reducing the risk of exploiting ImageMagick's capabilities for potential attacks.

Under Linux, select the policy with the `--with-security-policy={open,limited,secure,websafe}` configure script option. Under Windows, the choice is presented when you run the configure app.

We encourage you to review each rule in your `policy.xml` configuration file. Adjust the parameters according to your organization's requirements. You can modify the allowed image formats, set specific paths, and restrict certain operations based on your security needs. Remember that customizing the security policy is a delicate balance between functionality and security. Overly restrictive policies might hinder legitimate image processing tasks, while overly permissive policies can introduce vulnerabilities.

## Example Security Policy

Here is an example security policy:

    <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
    <!DOCTYPE policymap [
    <!ELEMENT policymap (policy)*>
    <!ATTLIST policymap xmlns CDATA #FIXED "">
    <!ELEMENT policy EMPTY>
    <!ATTLIST policy xmlns CDATA #FIXED "">
    <!ATTLIST policy domain NMTOKEN #REQUIRED>
    <!ATTLIST policy name NMTOKEN #IMPLIED>
    <!ATTLIST policy pattern CDATA #IMPLIED>
    <!ATTLIST policy rights NMTOKEN #IMPLIED>
    <!ATTLIST policy stealth NMTOKEN #IMPLIED>
    <!ATTLIST policy value CDATA #IMPLIED>
    ]>
    <!--
      Creating a security policy that fits your specific local environment
      before making use of ImageMagick is highly advised. You can find guidance on
      setting up this policy at https://imagemagick.org/www/security-policy.html,
      and it's important to verify your policy using the validation tool located
      at https://imagemagick-secevaluator.doyensec.com/.

      Web-safe ImageMagick security policy:

      This security protocol designed for web-safe usage focuses on situations
      where ImageMagick is applied in publicly accessible contexts, like websites.
      It deactivates the capability to read from or write to any image formats
      other than web-safe formats like GIF, JPEG, and PNG. Additionally, this
      policy prohibits the execution of image filters and indirect reads, thereby
      thwarting potential security breaches. By implementing these limitations,
      the web-safe policy fortifies the safeguarding of systems accessible to
      the public, reducing the risk of exploiting ImageMagick's capabilities
      for potential attacks.
    -->
    <policymap>
      <!-- Set maximum parallel threads. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="thread" value="2"/>
      <!-- Set maximum time in seconds or neumonics, e.g. "2 minutes". When this
           limit is exceeded, an exception is thrown and processing stops. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="time" value="60"/>
      <!-- Set maximum number of open pixel cache files. When this limit is
           exceeded, any subsequent pixels cached to disk are closed and reopened
           on demand. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="file" value="768"/>
      <!-- Set maximum amount of memory in bytes to allocate for the pixel cache
           from the heap. When this limit is exceeded, the image pixels are cached
           to memory-mapped disk. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="memory" value="256MiB"/>
      <!-- Set maximum amount of memory map in bytes to allocate for the pixel
           cache. When this limit is exceeded, the image pixels are cached to
           disk. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="map" value="512MiB"/>
      <!-- Set the maximum width * height of an image that can reside in the pixel
           cache memory. Images that exceed the area limit are cached to disk. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="area" value="16KP"/>
      <!-- Set maximum amount of disk space in bytes permitted for use by the pixel
           cache. When this limit is exceeded, the pixel cache is not be created
           and an exception is thrown. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="disk" value="1GiB"/>
      <!-- Set the maximum length of an image sequence.  When this limit is
           exceeded, an exception is thrown. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="list-length" value="16"/>
      <!-- Set the maximum width of an image.  When this limit is exceeded, an
           exception is thrown. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="width" value="4KP"/>
      <!-- Set the maximum height of an image.  When this limit is exceeded, an
           exception is thrown. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="height" value="4KP"/>
      <!-- Periodically yield the CPU for at least the time specified in
           milliseconds. -->
      <policy domain="resource" name="throttle" value="2"/>
      <!-- Do not create temporary files in the default shared directories, instead
           specify a private area to store only ImageMagick temporary files. -->
      <!--  -->
      <!-- Force memory initialization by memory mapping select memory
           allocations. -->
      <policy domain="cache" name="memory-map" value="anonymous"/>
      <!-- Ensure all image data is fully flushed and synchronized to disk. -->
      <policy domain="cache" name="synchronize" value="true"/>
      <!-- Replace passphrase for secure distributed processing -->
      <!--  -->
      <!-- Do not permit any delegates to execute. -->
      <policy domain="delegate" rights="none" pattern="*"/>
      <!-- Do not permit any image filters to load. -->
      <policy domain="filter" rights="none" pattern="*"/>
      <!-- Don't read/write from/to stdin/stdout. -->
      <policy domain="path" rights="none" pattern="-"/>
      <!-- don't read sensitive paths. -->
      <policy domain="path" rights="none" pattern="/etc/*"/>
      <!-- Indirect reads are not permitted. -->
      <policy domain="path" rights="none" pattern="@*"/>
      <!-- Deny all image modules and specifically exempt reading or writing
           web-safe image formats. -->
      <policy domain="module" rights="none" pattern="*" />
      <policy domain="module" rights="read | write" pattern="{GIF,JPEG,PNG,WEBP}" />
      <!-- This policy sets the number of times to replace content of certain
           memory buffers and temporary files before they are freed or deleted. -->
      <policy domain="system" name="shred" value="1"/>
      <!-- Enable the initialization of buffers with zeros, resulting in a minor
           performance penalty but with improved security. -->
      <policy domain="system" name="memory-map" value="anonymous"/>
      <!-- Set the maximum amount of memory in bytes that is permitted for
           allocation requests. -->
      <policy domain="system" name="max-memory-request" value="256MiB"/>
    </policymap>

To prevent one session from consuming all available memory when processing multiple sessions at the same time, large images are cached to disk with this policy. If an image exceeds the pixel cache disk limit, the program will exit. Additionally, a time limit has been set to prevent any processing tasks from running for too long. If an image has a width or height larger than 8192 pixels, or if an image sequence has more than 32 frames, processing will stop and an exception will be thrown.

Starting with ImageMagick 6.9.4-6, you can prevent the use of any delegate or all delegates (by setting the pattern to "*"). Prior to these releases, you can use the domain of `coder` and set rights to none and the glob pattern to HTTPS to prevent delegate usage. Additionally, users are prevented from executing any image filters and from performing indirect reads. If you want to, for example, read text from a file (e.g. `caption:@myCaption.txt`), you'll need to disable this path policy.

Policy glob patterns, before ImageMagick 6.9.12-94, are case sensitive. To get expected behavior, coders and modules must be upper-case (e.g. "EPS" not "eps") or use a case-insensitive pattern such as `[Pp][Nn][Gg]`.

Here is what you can expect when you restrict the HTTPS coder, for example:

    $ magick https://imagemagick.org/images/wizard.png wizard.jpg
    convert: attempt to perform an operation not allowed by the security policy `HTTPS'
    convert: no images defined `wizard.jpg'

As of ImageMagick version 6.9.7-9, you can conveniently deny access to all delegates and coders except for a small subset of proven web-safe image types. For example,

    <policy domain="delegate" rights="none" pattern="*" />
    <policy domain="module" rights="none" pattern="*" />
    <policy domain="module" rights="read | write" pattern="{GIF,JPEG,PNG,WEBP}" />

The module policy enables or disables a complete module for both read or write. To just read or write an image format, use the coder policy instead. For example, we disable reading just a few Postscript related formats, however, you can still write them:

    <policy domain="coder" rights="write" pattern="{PDF,PS,PS2,PS3,XPS}" />

As of ImageMagick 6.9.9-11, you can allocate the pixel cache and some internal buffers with anonymous memory mapping rather than from heap. As a consequence, the pixels are initialized to zero resulting in a minor performance penalty. You can also jumble the contents of certain memory buffers (requires version 6.1.12-53) and temporary files before they are freed or deleted. The shred value is the number of times to replace content with random data. For example,

    <policy domain="system" name="memory-map" value="anonymous"/>
    <policy domain="cache" name="memory-map" value="anonymous"/>
    <policy domain="system" name="shred" value="1"/>

For performance reasons, the first pass is fast by repeating the random sequence as necessary to overwrite the contents of the buffer or file. Subsequent passes are an order of magnitude slower, but generate cryptographically strong random bytes for the length of the buffer or file.

Some image processing algorithms (e.g. wavelet transform) might consume a substantial amount of memory to complete. ImageMagick maintains a separate memory pool for these large resource requests and as of 6.9.9-0 permits you to set a maximum request limit. If the limit is exceeded, the allocation is instead memory-mapped on disk. Here we limit the maximum memory request by policy:

    <policy domain="system" name="max-memory-request" value="256MiB"/>

As of ImageMagick version 6.9.9-35, you can limit the maximum number of images in a sequence. For example, to limit an image sequence to at most 64 frames, use:

    <policy domain="resource" name="list-length" value="64"/>

Note, numeric values in policies are floating-point with an optional SI prefix (e.g., 10MiB).

For additional details about resource limits and the policy configuration file, read Resources and Architecture.

As of ImageMagick 6.9.10-11, you can programmatically set the ImageMagick security policy with SetMagickSecurityPolicy() (MagickCore) or MagickSetSecurityPolicy() (MagickWand).

As of ImageMagick version 6.9.10-11, you can set a `module` security policy. For example, to prevent Postscript or PDF interpretation, use:

    <policy domain="module" rights="none" pattern="{ps,pdf,xps}/>

As of ImageMagick version 6.9.10-52, you can set a `font` policy. Specify a path to a Unicode font that ImageMagick defaults to whenever the user does not specify a font preference:

    <policy domain="system" name="font" value="/usr/share/fonts/arial-unicode.ttf"/>

Note, in file path glob patterns, use the backslash character (\) to escape characters that would otherwise be interpreted as special characters. For example:

    <policy domain="path" rights="none" pattern="c:\\\\*"/>

You can verify your policy changes are in effect with this command:

    $ magick identify -list policy
    Path: ImageMagick-7/policy.xml
      Policy: Cache
        name: memory-map
        value: anonymous
      Policy: Cache
        name: synchronize
        value: true
      Policy: Resource
        name: list-length
        value: 32
      Policy: Resource
        name: time
        value: 120
      Policy: Resource
        name: thread
        value: 2
      Policy: Resource
        name: file
        value: 768
      Policy: Resource
        name: disk
        value: 1GiB
      Policy: Resource
        name: map
        value: 512MiB
      Policy: Resource
        name: memory
        value: 256MiB
      Policy: Resource
        name: area
        value: 16KP
      Policy: Resource
        name: height
        value: 8KP
      Policy: Resource
        name: width
        value: 8KP
      Policy: Resource
        name: temporary-path
        value: /opt/tmp
      Policy: Coder
        rights: Write
        pattern: {HTTP,HTTPS,MVG,PS,PDF}
      Policy: Filter
        rights: None
        pattern: *
      Policy: Path
        rights: None
        pattern: @*
      Policy: System
        name: font
        value: ImageMagick-7/arial-unicode.ttf

    Path: [built-in]
      Policy: Undefined
        rights: None

Notice the `shared-secret` policy is not listed due to the `stealth` property.

Doyensec provides a policy evaluator tool that can assist you in designing and auditing your security policy. The tool is found at imagemagick-secevaluator.doyensec.com.

## Pixel Cache Synchronize Policy

When writing image pixels to disk, ImageMagick first preallocates the disk file, which is faster than fully populating the file with zeros. To improve performance even further, the file is memory-mapped on disk. This can result in an increase in performance of up to 5 times, but there is a possibility that the disk file may run out of free space as it is populated, causing the operating system (OS) to throw a SIGBUS signal which prevents ImageMagick from continuing. To prevent a SIGBUS signal from occurring, use this security policy:

    <policy domain="cache" name="synchronize" value="True"/>

Set to True to ensure all image data is fully flushed and synchronized to disk. There is a performance penalty, however, the benefits include ensuring a valid image file in the event of a system crash and early reporting if there is not enough disk space for the image pixel cache.

## Zero Configuration Security Policy

A zero configuration build of ImageMagick does not permit external configuration files. To define your security policy, you must instead edit the `MagickCore/policy-private.h` source module, add your policy statements, and then build the ImageMagick distribution. Here is an example zero configuration security policy:

    static const char
      *ZeroConfigurationPolicy = \
    "<policymap> \
      <policy domain=\"coder\" rights=\"none\" pattern=\"MVG\"/> \
    </policymap>";

## Other Security Considerations

If you spot a vulnerability in ImageMagick, first determine if the vulnerability can be mitigated by the security policy. ImageMagick, by default, is open. Use the security policy to add constraints to meet the requirements of your local security governance. If you feel confident that the security policy does not address the vulnerability, post the vulnerability as a security advisory. Most vulnerabilities are reviewed and resolved within 48 hours.

There are several ways to keep ImageMagick safer:

1. Use web-safe image formats: Limiting ImageMagick to only reading or writing web-safe image formats like GIF, JPEG, and PNG can help increase security.
2. Customize the security policy: You can customize the security policy to fit the needs of your local environment or organizational policies. This policy can cover aspects such as memory usage, allowable paths for reading and writing, the number of images allowed in a sequence, the maximum time a workflow can run, the amount of disk space allowed for image pixels, a secret passphrase for remote connections, and which coders are permitted or denied.
3. Set limits on resource usage: You can set limits on resources such as memory usage, disk space, and workflow runtime to prevent potentially harmful situations.
4. Use sandboxing: Sandboxing is a security technique that allows you to run a program in a restricted environment to prevent it from accessing sensitive information or making changes to the system.
5. Disable potentially dangerous coders: If you are using ImageMagick on a public website, you may want to increase security by disabling certain coders such as MVG or HTTPS.
6. Prevent execution of image filters and indirect reads: You can prevent users from executing image filters and performing indirect reads to increase security.
7. Use a current version of ImageMagick: It is important to use a current version of ImageMagick to take advantage of the latest security fixes and updates.